
ferguson19274 asked: I’ve heard the phrase “guard your heart” used a few times around my church, and the other day I realized that I don’t really know what it means. So far as I can guess, it has something to do with making sure your level of emotional attachment matches up with your level of commitment in the relationship, but I suspect there might be more. Your thoughts? Gracias.

Unka Glen answered: De nada, sobrino. The phrase “guard your heart” comes from scripture, but as we shall see, it isn’t always applied correctly. First, the verses— from Proverbs 4:23 “Above all else, guard your heart, for everything you do flows from it.”, and from Philippians 4:7 “The peace of God, which transcends all understanding, will guard your hearts and your minds in Christ Jesus”.
Well, there isn’t much there about dating. But if you were to apply this Biblical idea of “guarding one’s heart” to dating relationships, that would basically lead you to the concept of boundaries within relationships.
The simple idea there is that you can, and should, protect yourself from unnecessary pain and abuse by setting healthy emotional boundaries. So for example, you decide that things like namecalling, manipulations, and game-playing are unacceptable emotional lines to cross, and when those lines are crossed, those relationships change, and in some cases, they end. Similarly you set sexual/physical boundaries, and spiritual boundaries as well.
These boundaries should be set by praying through what God says is acceptable, and not acceptable, for you. This would embody the Biblical concept of guarding one’s heart, and many, including myself, have used this verse in this way, to point to the need for healthy boundaries within people’s lives.
Is prayerful boundary-setting what the people in your church are referring to? Well… probably not. There has, in recent Christian culture, emerged a rather odd, poorly thought-out notion, that when you fall in love with someone romantically, that you give them “pieces of your heart”, and you have to guard yourself against doing that, lest you have no pieces of heart left over to give to your eventual spouse.
Given a just few moments to think about it, we see that this simply isn’t how love works. A mother loves her child with all she has, and when she has a second child, she doesn’t find that she has less of her heart to give, she finds that her heart has expanded, and that God fills her heart with more and more love, as she pours it out.
Our experiences, even our failures, help us to grow, becoming wiser and better prepared for our eventual spouse. Also, in all fairness, as I’ve mentioned before, one of those people who helped promote these poorly-thought-out ideas on dating, Joshua Harris, has worked to distance himself from those ideas, and considering that he was single, young, and not an experienced marital counselor when he wrote about dating and marriage, I think it’s fair to cut him that slack.
When it comes to managing relationships, you’re going to hear a lot that’s designed to make you afraid, as a way of keeping you in line (or keep you away from relationships altogether). But in the long run, fear isn’t a useful substitute for wisdom. The whole point of knowing where those boundaries are, is being able to relax once you’re within them, and HAVE FUN. Within those boundaries, you should be passionate, romantic, and fearless.